1900 Victorian house in Monticello, Indiana – $799k

Stunning Victorian house for sale in Monticello, Indiana. Built in 1900, updated while retaining authentic craftsmanship and original woodwork, boathouse, 4986 square feet. $799,900.

1900 Victorian house Monticello Indiana - front view
Listen to this article

House overview

Beautiful Victorian waterfront home. A perfect blend of old meets new.

Meticulously renovated and updated to offer the modern day updates you want. Maintaining the original, authentic craftsmanship of an architecturally significant home.

This George Barber design home includes 10 ft ceilings, original woodwork, 3 sets of pocket doors, crystal chandelier, parquet floors, gas fireplace, built in china cabinets, and leaded glass window.


In the kitchen you will find gorgeous Amish quarter sawn oak cabinets, 42 inch uppers, stainless steel appliances, and granite countertops. The second staircase off of the kitchen. Also included is the original restored ice chest. First floor has a beautiful open flow that is perfect for entertaining.

The second floor has 4 large bedrooms. The primary bedroom features a makeup area, ensuite bathroom, clawfoot tub, custom cabinetry, and a walk-in shower.

Also, the second floor offers a 4 season sunroom with great tree top views and a private balcony. The second-floor guest bathroom has been completely renovated.

The amazing 3rd story includes a great room with original hardwood floors, book shelves, powder room, wet bar, cozy reading nook, and a turret featuring 22 ft high ceiling.

Outdoor and basement

  • The well manicured, landscaped yard is fully fenced.

  • Outdoor space at the house includes a brick paver patio and trex deck off of the kitchen.

  • Garage is 24 foot x 34 foot, heated with a walk up second story.

  • Huge dry basement with tiled floors, spacious laundry room, tons of storage, craft room, and a workshop or playroom for the kids.


  • New 200 amp service with 100% new electric, 80% of it in conduit.

  • All new copper water pipes with manifold system.

  • Newer boiler with all new copper piping and zone control.

  • New 8 inch schedule 60 sewer line with anti backflow.

  • New windows throughout.

  • Original curved glass windows re-glazed and hung.

  • Upgraded Certain Teed siding exterior.

  • All external wood surfaces taken down to the base condition, primed and 3 coats of paint.

  • Fully alarmed with radio back up.


Take the new staircase or fully refurbished funicular down to the waterfront. You will find 65ft of shoreline, seawall, 3 covered boat lifts, expansive composite deck with a boathouse, cement stairs with railing into water for easy access for all. Also, a stainless steel fish cleaning table.

A truly magnificent home will have you living your best lake life!


Photo gallery (1-8)

Photo gallery (9-22)

Photo gallery (23-35)

House plans

1900 Victorian house Monticello Indiana - house plans